Here's what I had hanging around my stash and brief opinions on each:
Weleda Pomegranate Firming Eye Cream
I liked how lightweight this was during the hotter weather. It gives a slight tightening feeling as it goes on, but it didn't do much of anything for my dark circles or puffiness. Smelled fruity but not overpoweringly so.
Weleda Wild Rose Smoothing Eye Cream
Still pretty light, but a little heavier than the Pomegranate, this was definitely my favorite of the two Weleda eye creams. Again, I didn't notice drastic results, but it helped a little with puffiness and was great under makeup. The scent was also mild and completely non-offensive, even for a non-rose lover like me.
Kahina Giving Beauty Eye Serum
I love other Kahina products, but this one just didn't do it for me. I didn't notice any difference in my eye area, and I wasn't impressed with the slight tacky film that the serum leaves behind after it dries. Layering another cream on top gets rid of the tackiness, but I'm still not completely sold.
Consonant Ultra Moisturizing + Ultra Firming Organic Eye Creams
I'm grouping these together because, honestly, I didn't notice a big difference between the two. They're both thick, rich, unscented creams that work really well for puffyness. If puffy eyes are your main concern, they're fabulous - they work better in that regard than anything else I've tried - but they didn't do much for dark circles. I also find them a little too heavy for mornings, if I don't have time to wait before applying makeup.
Young Living Wolfberry Eye Cream (not pictured)
When my mom heard I was testing eye creams, she gave me a sample of her eye cream to try too. I used to use this as a teenager, and I do notice it makes my dark circles a little bit lighter. It's good at night, but like the Consonant, I don't love it in the morning, since it needs that little extra time to soak in before I can comfortably apply concealer on top.
The Bottom Line
My under eye area is probably my biggest skin concern these days, so I can be a bit fussy with eye products. I know you can't always adequately judge something like this from just using a sample, but nonetheless, none of these sold me enough that I'll be buying the full size. I'm still on the fence about what I want to use. I really like the Pure + Simple, but after almost a year, I'm up for using something different....
What are your favorite eye products? I'm totally open to recommendations!
Contains affiliate links.